Why a Lovesick Soldier’s Secret Helped Scotland Reclaim Its Greatest Castle

Edinburgh Castle had stood in English hands for nearly two decades. Getting it back would take something the English never anticipated — a young man’s old love affair, a moonless night in March, and fewer than thirty Scots who were willing to climb.

The Castle Scotland Could Not Afford to Lose

When Edward I marched north in 1296 and seized Edinburgh Castle, he took more than stone and mortar. He took Scotland’s most visible symbol of sovereignty.

Castle Rock rises nearly 130 metres above the city on a sheer volcanic plug of ancient basalt. Its north face was considered nature’s own defence — near-vertical, black, and slick — the kind of cliff that generals look at and cross off the list of options. The fortress had stood unconquered by direct assault for as long as anyone could recall.

By 1314, Robert the Bruce had been methodically reclaiming Scotland, siege by siege, skirmish by skirmish. Castle after castle had fallen back into Scottish hands. Edinburgh remained — a stone declaration, planted high above the capital, that Scotland was still occupied.

If Bruce was to carry Scotland to Bannockburn, he needed this castle first. He gave the task to his nephew, Sir Thomas Randolph, Earl of Moray.

What a Lovesick Boy Left Behind

Randolph could have mounted a conventional siege. He had the men for it. Instead, a soldier named William Francis came forward with something worth more than any battering ram: a memory.

As a young man, Francis had been posted to Edinburgh Castle as part of the English garrison. He was young and restless — and, by most traditional accounts, in love with a girl who lived below in the city.

The gates were locked at night. The obvious exits were guarded. But Francis had discovered, through the kind of determination that only the young and lovesick seem to possess, that the north face was not quite as impossible as it looked.

A crack here. A ledge there. A sequence of handholds that a nimble climber could follow by touch in the dark. He had made the descent and return countless times without detection, slipping back before dawn as if he had never left.

Decades later, when Randolph asked how a man might get into Edinburgh Castle unseen, Francis told him exactly where to put his hands.

Thirty Men and a Moonless Night

On a dark night in March 1314 — just three months before Bannockburn — Randolph gathered his small company at the foot of Castle Rock’s northern face.

Thirty men. Climbing in near-darkness, in armour, trusting the memory of one man’s adolescent escapades, one handhold at a time. There was no rope. There was no going back quietly if someone slipped.

Francis led them up. The climb was desperate — a stumble meant a long fall to the rocks below, and the noise would have woken the entire garrison. The night was cold. The basalt was wet.

Halfway up, a sentry on the wall called out: “I see you!” He paused — and then moved on, apparently dismissing the movement on the supposedly unclimbable face as a trick of shadow and tired eyes.

The Scots reached the parapet. They hauled themselves over, drew their weapons, and overwhelmed the garrison before any coherent defence could be mounted. By morning, Edinburgh Castle was Scottish once more.

The Decision That Still Staggers

What Bruce did next is perhaps even more remarkable than the raid itself.

Having won Edinburgh Castle at such extraordinary cost, he ordered it torn down.

Not out of anger or celebration — but cold strategic calculation. Bruce had watched too many Scottish fortresses fall back into English hands after being won. A castle that could not be held was a castle that could be used against Scotland.

So Edinburgh Castle was slighted — its towers reduced, its gates broken, its walls dismantled stone by stone. Only decades later, under David II, would it be rebuilt into the stronghold that still dominates the skyline today.

It was the act of a man who understood that destroying your most powerful symbol of victory could be the most strategically brilliant move of all. Few decisions in Scottish history are as quietly extraordinary.

What You See When You Look North

When you visit Edinburgh Castle — and if you’re planning time in Edinburgh, it is not to be missed — walk to the northern edge and look down.

The drop is vertiginous. The rock is sheer, black, and wet-looking even in summer. It is genuinely hard to imagine climbing it in full daylight, let alone in darkness and armour.

But thirty men did. Led by a guide who had first made that same climb for nothing more complicated than love.

Scotland’s history is full of these moments — where the most human detail, the most unlikely private act, turns the tide of something enormous. Another castle story shows how Scots used the same stubborn ingenuity to save the Crown Jewels from Cromwell three centuries later.

If you want to walk the ground of Scotland’s remarkable heritage for yourself, Edinburgh Castle is the place to begin. The north face still bears no path, no ladder, no signage. Only the silence of what was done there, once, in the dark.

Download our free Scotland Travel Guide (PDF)